towards a Privacy Amendment
Jun. 29th, 2005 10:35 amYesterday I started thinking that it's about time we start talking nationally about having an amendment to the US Constitution protecting individual privacy. It would buy us a few decades, perhaps.
I decided to poke around to see if other people are thinking similarly, and it turns out that some people are.
One reply to that post argues that the Fourth Amendment protection against "unreasonable searches and seizures" is sufficient. I disagree: that coverage does not deal at all with data-gathering by the government, the sharing of data between government and contractors, and so on. It does not deal with casual surveilance of city streets -- which, hey, may or may not be a bad thing, but let's discuss it before more cameras and satellites go up.
I'm disconcerted about the ways Americans (and our friends in Europe are even farther along than we are) are being step-by-step aclimatized to the idea of sharing information with anyone who asks, and allowing our habits and activities to be tracked by any business or government who seems to care. By ceding our privacy we are taking it on faith that no one will ever abuse what they have on us; human history suggests this is a poor risk to take.
I decided to poke around to see if other people are thinking similarly, and it turns out that some people are.
One reply to that post argues that the Fourth Amendment protection against "unreasonable searches and seizures" is sufficient. I disagree: that coverage does not deal at all with data-gathering by the government, the sharing of data between government and contractors, and so on. It does not deal with casual surveilance of city streets -- which, hey, may or may not be a bad thing, but let's discuss it before more cameras and satellites go up.
I'm disconcerted about the ways Americans (and our friends in Europe are even farther along than we are) are being step-by-step aclimatized to the idea of sharing information with anyone who asks, and allowing our habits and activities to be tracked by any business or government who seems to care. By ceding our privacy we are taking it on faith that no one will ever abuse what they have on us; human history suggests this is a poor risk to take.